McFarlane v Tayside Health Board [1999]


  • A doctor performed a sterilisation operation on the father, negligently such that it reversed and caused the wrongful birth of a healthy child


  • Could the parents make a mother’s claim and a parents’ claim against the hospital


  • The mother’s claim was allowed, the parents’ claim disallowed


  • A court could not issue an adoption or abortion law (the latter not applicable in this case)
  • It is morally unacceptable to allow the claim
  • The benefits of a child are incalculable. In truth, a child is a mixed blessing
  • It would be subversive to enjoy the benefits of a child but to transfer the responsibility to others

RELATED CASE  Murphy v Culhane [1977]

Posted in Tort Law Revision Notes.

This page was last updated on 3rd January 2014

© 2020 Webstroke Law - Terms and Privacy Policy