Environment Agency v Empress Car Co [1999]


  • The defendants left an unguarded tap on a large diesel tank next to a river
  • An unknown vandal trespassed on the property of the defendants and opened the tap, allowing the diesel to discharge into the river
  • It is a strict liability offence to cause the discharge of diesel into a river, under the Water Resources Act 1991, section 85


  • Did the defendants cause the discharge?


  • Yes


  • Having created the situation which allowed the discharge, the defendants would only escape liability if the intervening act was extraordinary
  • It was not extraordinary, given the local opposition to the defendants, that the tap might be opened by a vandal
RELATED CASE  The Queen v Beckford [1988, Privy Council, Jamaica]

Posted in Criminal Law Revision Notes.

This page was last updated on 24th December 2014

© 2020 Webstroke Law - Terms and Privacy Policy