Bourhill v Young [1943]


  • A pregnant lady (Bourhill), upon disembarking from a tram, went to collect her luggage from the luggage storage area
  • At the luggage storage area, she heard a motorcyclist crash (50ft away); the motorcyclist was killed by the crash. She later saw blood on the road
  • The pregnant lady suffered nervous shock and later gave birth to a stillborn child


  • Could the claimant recover from the estate of the motorcyclist


  • No recovery


  • There was no foreseeable harm or relationship between the motorcyclist and Bourhill, nor was their a close relationship


[1943] AC 92


RELATED CASE  R Addie & Sons v Dumbreck [1929]

Posted in Tort Law Revision Notes.

This page was last updated on 3rd January 2014

© 2020 Webstroke Law - Terms and Privacy Policy